Software QA testing – which is best Exploratory vs Scripted?

Many people have asked me which is better in software testing; exploratory vs scripted.

First, lets take a look at a basic explanation of each:

Scripted Testing (Wikipedia definition – Scripted Testing)

Scripted testing in regards to software testing is the detailed step-by-step approach to testing a specific piece of functionality.  Generally, a test writer or QA manager will write a test case with specific step by step instructions that will also explain the expected results of the test.

A tester can then follow along and will know, based on the expected outcome, what should happen at the end of the test.  Essentially, the tester will have “blinders” on and will do what they are instructed to do.  There is little deviation from the “script” or list of steps.

Exploratory Testing (Wikipedia definition – Exploratory Testing)

Exploratory testing in regards to software testing means to basically take the (aforementioned) “blinders” off.  Testers are given a page or section of a website with some high-level, basic functionality.  The tester will then go through the section of the website with little to no steps in place, and with no real expected outcome.   Exploratory by its very definition is unscripted and improvisational.

This type of testing really challenges the tester to think and function as an end-user.  Exploratory testing also challenges the tester to try and break the website by performing things that may really be outside a normal testing scenario.

Comparing scripted vs. exploratory:

Scripted Testing – is usually very time intensive up front in order to write each step within a test case.  Also, if the steps are too specific, they can become invalid or irrelevant if the deliverables are amended or changed.  This would require maintenance to go back through and ensure that the test cases are still valid.

However, scripted testing can also ensure that each and every piece of functionality has been tested and passed as well as ensuring that all deliverables have been met.  Scripted testing can also become automated which can help re-run tests for regression purposes in a very quick manner.

Exploratory Testing – is usually performed in the moment and the tests cannot be reviewed in advance.  The tester has basically created the test on the fly.  Other than the notes made during testing and review after the fact, there is no confirmation that all the requirements or deliverables have been met.  Another drawback of exploratory testing is that it cannot be automated.

On the other hand, exploratory testing has much less preparation and can be scheduled and performed quickly.  Severe bugs can be found sooner than later, which always saves time and money.

Exploratory testing is also much more stimulating for the tester and they usually feel more invested in the process.

In conclusion:

Testing should always be a combination of both scripted AND exploratory testing.   There are definite benefits and drawbacks to both.  The amount of one over the other will always depend on the situation and where in the SDLC (Software Development Life Cycle) the project is in.  Other circumstances may always come into play like performing a demo for a stakeholder, or a release of new functionality.

But a good test plan will always incorporate both testing strategies.

Do you have any thoughts or comments??  Let me know what you think…

Ben Cato

These days, I love the people I work with and I love what I do. I specialize in front-end development (HTML5, CSS3, LESS, SASS, JS, GSAP and Photoshop / Illustrator / Sketch App).

More posts from Ben >

2 comments on Software QA testing – which is best Exploratory vs Scripted?

KateNovember 11, 2017 - Reply

Hi Ben,

Could you please tell what are the similarities between exploratory testing and scripted testing?

Thank you!

Kate

SimoneNovember 22, 2019 - Reply

I love your stuff
Hey, Been reading your site for a while just wanted to say
I enjoy it aas nobody seems to say positive things online now
Honestly this is probably the most helpful thing I’ve read, thanks a lot.
From cold Scotland
did you mean to say always here, or something else?

Hey, I dont comment online muych but this
is rreally helpful for me as I’m jsut getting started
Your site is slowwww. If you want I know a few hosrs that are cheap but
reliable. Noot spam or selling anything just thought I’d
let yyou know thanks.
Hi, Not spam but just wantesd to say thanks
this is really useful stuff foor someone like me.
I thought the offer would be workng toiday but when I went to try it, it doesn’t work.

I cant get that link to work, am I doing something wrong
hi. cannot get that link to work it shows an error am I doing it right
Hi I love this site and dont want to be negative but I am using Chrome and it doesnt display right
Ijust left a comment and I saw the comment and I refreshed
the screen annd the comment is gone.
I left a coment butt then when I refreshed it, it had disappeared.
Trying again and will this one do the same????

Hi mate, before I thank you for this and apologize because it
not good at English, and I uuse gooogle translate buut juyst want to say thanks

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Or request call back